The first, a 2018 pullout study by Genedy, Chennareddy, Stenko and Reda Taha, embedded No. 4 and No. 5 bars in PMMA polymer concrete. All six bars embedded eight bar diameters (8d), three of each size, fractured instead of pulling out. For the No. 4 bar, 8d is 4 in (102 mm). Our reading: in these tests, bond did not limit an 8d embedment. The steel did.
What did the pullout tests use?
The mix was methyl methacrylate resin, benzoyl peroxide initiator and well-graded aggregate (1 in, 25.4 mm nominal maximum) at 6.2% resin by weight, cured at about 72 °F (22 °C). Five cylinders averaged 9,780 psi (67.4 MPa) compressive strength.
No. 4 (0.5 in, 12.7 mm) and No. 5 (0.625 in, 15.9 mm) bars (nominal yield 60 ksi, 413 MPa) were cast into cylinders at 4d, 6d, 8d and 10d, three specimens per case, and pulled after one week. Cylinder dimensions, and so cover and confinement, are not reported.
| Embedment | No. 4 bar | No. 5 bar |
|---|---|---|
| 4d | all debonded | all debonded, after yield |
| 6d | some ruptured, some debonded after yield (split not reported) | all ruptured |
| 8d | all ruptured | all ruptured |
| 10d | all ruptured | all ruptured |
How does that become a development length?
Back-calculated from the specimens that debonded, bond strength was 3,670 psi (25.3 MPa) for No. 4 and 4,190 psi (28.9 MPa) for No. 5; the paper does not say which specimens entered each average. Setting yield force equal to bond force gives l_d = f_y·d / (4·f_d), or 4.1d for No. 4 (about 2.0 in, 52 mm) and 3.6d for No. 5 (about 2.2 in, 57 mm). The authors cite ACI 318-14 at no less than 24d for normal concrete of similar strength.
Do not read those figures against 24d directly: a code length carries design factors, and a lower-bound bond value would sit below an average. The rupture results, unlike the calculated lengths, do not depend on nominal yield.
What do the beam tests add?
A pullout cylinder isolates the bond of a single bar. A closure joint laps bars from two panels, with splitting resisted only by the cover. In 2019, Mantawy, Chennareddy, Genedy and Reda Taha, three of the same four authors, reported four-point bending tests on 6 in (152 mm) square beams with lapped No. 4 bars and 3d of cover (1.5 in, 38 mm), three beams per lap length from 1d to 7d, tested at 7 days. Its mix differs: 3/4 in (19 mm) aggregate and 10,530 psi (72.6 MPa) strength.
- Every beam lapped 5d or less failed by bar slip; at 5d the bars yielded first.
- At 6d and 7d, some beams slipped and some bars ruptured (split not reported).
Pullout bars all ruptured at 8d, but the beams stopped at 7d (3.5 in, 89 mm), so neither paper tests a 4 in lap with known cover.
Taken together: beam laps of 5d or less slipped, those at 5d after yielding; No. 4 pullouts at 6d and beam laps at 6d to 7d gave mixed results; every No. 4 bar broke at 8d, tested in pullout only.
What limits this?
Each paper tests a single PMMA mix, lab-cured at about 72 °F (22 °C) and loaded at 7 days. One 2018 co-author, Michael Stenko, was listed with Transpo Industries. The 2018 paper does not identify the resin product.
What should a specifier ask?
"The steel yielded," "the steel broke" and "this joint is ready to specify" are three different claims. The data support the first two for these specimens, not the third. For an accelerated bridge project, the sharper question is how much load the splice can carry at the age traffic returns, with the cover and curing temperature the joint will actually see. Neither paper tests ages under 7 days, field cover or field temperatures.
References
Genedy, M., Chennareddy, R., Stenko, M., & Reda Taha, M. M. (2018). Development length of steel reinforcement in polymer concrete for bridge deck closure. In M. M. Reda Taha (Ed.), International Congress on Polymers in Concrete (ICPIC 2018) (pp. 329–335). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-78175-4_41
Mantawy, I., Chennareddy, R., Genedy, M., & Reda Taha, M. (2019). Polymer concrete for bridge deck closure joints in accelerated bridge construction. Infrastructures, 4(2), 31. https://doi.org/10.3390/infrastructures4020031
